Lighter Classic Sloppy Joes

These lighter, healthier Sloppy Joes have all the rich, savory, full-bodied flavor you're craving! (Super-easy recipe | no cans, no mixes)

Jump to:

• What's the Story Behind this Recipe?
• How We Made Sloppy Joes Healthier
• What Goes into this Recipe
• How to Make this Recipe
• FAQs & Expert Tips
• Related Recipes
• Lighter Classic Sloppy Joes

What's the Story Behind this Recipe?

We had some amazing lunch ladies at my elementary school when I was growing up. They baked us fresh bread nearly every day, and served up what I have come to learn was some of the finest school food offered in the Portland Public School District at the time.

Sloppy Joe Day was always a good day in our lunchroom! (Almost as good as Pizza Day!) I remember passing through the lunch line, watching as the Sloppy Joe lady plunked a big ice cream scoop full of thick, meaty sauce onto the bottom half of a freshly baked burger bun, where it sat like a little brown igloo until she smooshed it into a patty shape with the other half of the bun. 

Once at your table, you would hold your Sloppy Joe in both hands, fingers on top, thumbs down. The trick was to keep it level as you bit down, in the hopes that at least some of the filling would stay inside the bun as you did. I nearly always finished mine with a fork though, as most of my Joe inevitably ended up plopping out on my lunch tray. 

The thing that made those lunch-lady cafeteria Sloppy Joes so good was they were made from scratch, like in our classic Sloppy Joe recipe. No cans, no mixes.

How We Made Sloppy Joes Healthier

In order to bring classic Sloppy Joes into the new millennia with lighter, healthier ingredients, we had to make a couple of changes to the basic recipe.

Mostly obviously, we substituted ground chicken for the traditional ground beef. (You can also use ground turkey.) Ground chicken, however, presents another problem, because it is essentially the tofu of live proteins; in that it is utterly tasteless all by itself. For a more positive spin, think of it as a blank canvas, just waiting for you to paint it up with your culinary magic. 

To recreate the rich, savory, beefy flavor that is the calling card of any respectable Sloppy Joe, we enhanced the mix with a splash of Worcestershire sauce and a little cocoa powder. We also added a handful of grated carrots for depth and sweetness, a squirt of Sriracha for a touch of heat, and a carefully chosen blend of savory herbs and spices.

Finally, because we prefer our Sloppy Joes to have some body, we added a little ground oatmeal. If you’ve never used the oatmeal trick to thicken a meat sauce before, it may sound weird; but it works like a charm. (You won't taste the oatmeal.)

What Goes into this Recipe

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

★ Ground chicken: This recipe was tested using ground chicken and ground turkey. Of course, you can also go traditional and use lean ground beef.

★ Oats: Use chopped or coarsely ground old-fashioned or quick oats for this recipe.

Do not use oat flour for this: it is too finely ground.

★ Ketchup: Any ketchup will work, but we always use Portland Ketchup for its rich depth of flavor.

Substitutions: You can sub in chili sauce for the ketchup. If you use chili sauce instead, we recommend using Heinz brand for the best results. In this case, omit the Sriracha and the brown sugar. We suggest using a 50/50 mixture of chili sauce and ketchup at most.

How to Make this Recipe

Stovetop Sloppy Joes

In a small bowl, mix together ketchup, brown sugar, Worcestershire sauce, cocoa powder, salt, Sriracha, basil, oregano, fennel seeds, and paprika. Set aside.

Melt butter in a large, heavy skillet over medium heat. Increase heat to medium-high and add chopped onions and celery. Stir intermittently until the onions just begin to brown.

Add ½ cup water and ground meat to skillet with the onions and celery. Break meat apart and cook until no pink remains and water has evaporated.

Add the grated carrots and the contents of small bowl to skillet mixture

Stir to combine thoroughly. Reduce heat to Low, cover skillet, and simmer 5 - 10 minutes.

If mix is too thick: Add up to a cup of water before simmering (Don't go crazy, though!)

After the mixture has simmered, thicken it by adding 2 -4 tablespoons of quick or old-fashioned oats.

Run the oats through a food mill or pulse them in small blender first. (Be careful though - you don't want to turn it into oat flour - you just want to break the oats up a little.)

Assemble Sloppy Joes immediately before serving.

Slow Cooker Sloppy Joes

Melt butter in a large, heavy skillet over medium heat. Increase heat to medium-high and add chopped onions and celery. Stir intermittently until the onions just begin to brown.

Add ½ cup water and ground meat to skillet with the onions and celery. Break meat apart and cook until no pink remains and water has evaporated.

Transfer to a slow cooker. Add all the remaining Sloppy Joe mix ingredients except the oatmeal. Cook in slow cooker on LOW for 1-2 hours.

Stir in chopped oatmeal and cook until thickened; about 5 minutes.

FAQs & Expert Tips

Homemade Sloppy Joes are even better on homemade buns! We like to serve these on our softy, airy homemade burger buns. If you'd like to learn more about making your own burger buns - it's super easy!!! Check out Homemade Hamburger Buns for more.

Sloppy Joes: Not Just for Buns! 

Never underestimate the versatility of the humble Sloppy Joe. Sure, it's great on a bun, but it has so much potential for branching out. Here are just a few ideas: 

• Sloppy Huevos Rancheros
• Sloppy Breakfast Tacos
• Sloppy Lasagna
• Sloppy Pasta
• Sloppy on a Shingle
• Sloppy Rice
• Sloppy Avocado 

Related Recipes

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, including Amazon affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that we have recommended. Please check out our disclosure policy for more details.