Savory Herb Pie Crust

Our tender, flaky Herb Pie Crust is the perfect wrapping for all your savory pies and pastries, and the herbs can easily be customized to complement any dish.

Jump to:

• What's the Story Behind this Recipe?
• Why this Recipe Works
• What Goes into this Recipe
• How to Make Basic Herbed Pie Crust
• FAQs & Expert Tips
• Related Recipes
• Savory Herb Pie Crust

What's the Story Behind this Recipe?

The foods we prepare for the people we love stays with them long after we are gone. My mother will always be remembered for her fruit pies and her spaghetti sauce and her chili mac. Simple, dependable, and delicious. When I remember Mr B's Great-Granny (who I first met when we were 15), I always think of her homemade egg noodles; and the smell of fried bologna always reminds me of my Grandma Lucy.

So what will you be remembered for? For me, my classic Italian lasagna is for sure in the running, as is Mr B's personal favorite; my Shepherd's Pie. (I have a few fans.)

But just as likely, I will be remembered for my Chicken Pot Pie, made with homemade chicken stock and oven roasted vegetables. The crowning touch on this most ultimate of comfort foods is a tender, flaky, golden crust infused with herbs specially chosen to complement the savory, creamy chicken filling.

Why this Recipe Works

This tender, flaky Herb Pie Crust is the perfect wrapping for all your savory pies and pastries, and the herbs can easily be customized to complement any dish. 

There are plenty of tips and tricks out there to help you achieve that perfect pie crust; however, in my experience, following these three basic rules will keep you on the road to tender, flaky, pie perfection every time!

3 Secrets to Perfect Pie Crust

Mom taught me three simple rules for making pie crust. 

1. Keep everything COLD. – The colder you can keep things, the more successful your crust will be. Refrigerate or freeze everything you are using to make your pastry dough, including your mixing bowl! If your dough starts feeling melty or too soft to work with, immediately put everything back in the fridge or freezer for a few minutes. You will never ruin your crust by taking some extra chill time. 
2. Incorporate fats by hand. – One of the leading causes of tough crust is that bits of fat in it are too small. (This is why I avoid using a food processor for making pastry crust.) I do, however, often coarsely grate my butter. (I usually chill it, along with the shortening, for at least an hour.) I find that this allows me to distribute it quicker, therein keeping everything colder. 
3. Do not overmix. – Gluten formation in pastry dough results a tough, chewy crust, and is to be avoided whenever possible. Gluten strands are formed the more you mix the dough. This is why you want to avoid over-mixing or kneading pastry dough once the liquid has been added. 

What Goes into this Recipe

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

★ Shortening: We use Crisco for making pies.

★ Butter: We use salted butter for herbed pie crust. Unsalted butter also works fine.

★ Flour: Use all-purpose white flour, bleached or unbleached.

Do not use bread flour for pie crust. It has too much protein and will make the crust tough and chewy.

★ Water: Water added to pie crust should always be ice cold!

★ Herbs: This recipe suggest using 1 teaspoon of Herbes de Provence or ½ tsp. dried sage + ½ tsp. dried thyme. Use whatever herbs will best complement whatever you are filling the pie with.

★ Salt: Salt adds flavor to pie crust. Leave it out and the crust will taste like cardboard. Use table salt or fine sea salt for pie crusts for best results.

How to Make Basic Herbed Pie Crust

In a medium bowl, whisk flour, dried herbs, and salt together with a fork.

Using a pastry cutter, fork, or your fingers (my personal choice) work the cold shortening into the flour mixture until the texture resembles that of strudel crumble.

Add coarsely grated (or cut) ice-cold butter to flour mixture. Work the butter in using a pastry cutter, fork, or your fingers.

It's OK to leave large pieces of butter (balls up to the size of a lima bean): this is what makes your pie crust flakey!

Cool flour mixture in freezer 5 minutes before proceeding.

Sprinkle ½ cup ice cold liquid (ice water, or ice water+vodka) over the top of the flour mixture and stir with a wooden spoon until a ball begins to form. (IMPORTANT: Do not pour liquid onto flour mixture: sprinkle it.)

Turn dough out onto counter and press together into a large ball or disk. (You may need to knead the dough a few times to get it to stick together, but the idea is to handle it as little as possible.)

Divide dough in half. (This will make it easier to work with later.) Press each half into a disk. Do not overwork the dough: just press it together. Wrap each disk tightly in plastic wrap.

Refrigerate prepared dough for at least one hour, and up to two days.

Roll out and bake according to directions for whatever you are making.

Standard Pastry Baking Times

• Single Crust Pie (Filled) • 400 - 425°F | 205-218°C • 35-55 minutes
• Pie Shell Only (Unfilled) • 450°F | 232 °C • 12-15 minutes
• Double-Crust (Uncooked Filling) • 400 - 425°F | 205-218°C • 45-55 minutes
• Double-Crust (Cooked Filling) • 425 - 450°F | 205-232 °C • 30-45 minutes

FAQs & Expert Tips

Use Parchment Paper for Rolling

This dough can be rolled out on a floured surface; however, I find that sandwiching dough between two parchment sheets allows me to roll it out smoothly without adding too much additional flour while dusting. It also allows me to turn it over easily to roll the opposite side. 

To do this:

1. Place your refrigerated dough disk between two sheets of parchment, dusting both sides lightly with flour before placing the top sheet.
2. Beginning in the center of the disk, roll away from you, then spin the dough about a quarter turn.
3. Repeat this motion, rolling from the center and turning a quarter turn, applying pressure evenly as you go.
4. Flip the entire thing over and repeat on the opposite side, rolling until you achieve the desired thickness.
5. Chill the dough for a few minutes if it becomes too soft or sticky.

Flour Hydration

Did you know that different types and brands of flour hydrate differently?

Flour varieties have fundamental differences between them, hydration being one of the most critical. That’s why water measurements in a pie ingredient list are often listed as estimates (i.e., add more as needed.) If you’re unsure if you need to add a bit more flour, allow the dough to rest in the fridge for an hour to give the flour a chance to absorb some of the liquid. If the dough still too soft, dust it with some extra flour as you roll it out. 

Related Recipes

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, including Amazon affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that we have recommended. Please check out our disclosure policy for more details.

Originally published November 1, 2012. Post has been updated with new content, images, and recipe instructions to improve reader experience.