Best Ever Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream

There are few things as refreshing as a scoop of Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream on a hot summer day, and this is the best fresh strawberry ice cream recipe you'll ever make!

Jump to:

• Why this Recipe Works
• What Goes into this Recipe
• How to Make this Recipe
• More Fresh Strawberry Recipes
• Homemade Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream

Why this Recipe Works

This fresh strawberry ice cream is - no exaggeration - the best strawberry ice cream I've ever had. I'll admit though, this recipe took Mr B and me some serious trial and error to put together. We wanted to get it just right, and so a lot of strawberry ice cream had to be made - and eaten - during the "research & development" phase. (Really - a LOT.)

Why Strawberries are Tricky

Making homemade strawberry ice cream is trickier than it looks. You'd think, just throw some strawberries, cream, and sugar together and you're golden, right? Wrong.

The biggest problem with fresh strawberry ice cream is the strawberries themselves. Strawberries have a very high water content, and what does water do when it get very, very cold? That's right, class - it freezes! Into little ice crystals. Which are fine for winter windows and root beer mugs, but no so great for ice cream.

To avoid having hard, crunchy strawberry ice cream, you have to do something to counteract water crystallization; hence the vodka and the corn syrup in this recipe. (Note: Any 70/80 proof liquor will work: we use whipped cream vodka.)

With a higher freezing temp than water, the alcohol in the vodka keeps discourages water crystallization, which in turn keeps your little strawberry chunks from turning into little strawberry ice cubes, while the corn syrup adds body, and keeps the texture smooth and supple.

What's So Different about this Strawberry Ice Cream Recipe?

If you've made strawberry ice cream before, you may find a few other things are different about this recipe:

♦︎ No Eggs: While eggs usually make for a richer ice cream, in the case of strawberry ice cream, they do so at the expense of that amazing fresh strawberry flavor - the exact thing that you want to preserve.

Another bonus for leaving the eggs out - no cooking necessary. (I'm not afraid of raw eggs, but you may be, and that's ok. Our eggs are produced in our backyard.) Anyway, that leads me to...

♦︎ No Cooking: Why? First off, you don't have eggs, so there's no reason to make a "custard base." Cooking also changes the flavor of the strawberries, and all I want to taste is sweet cream and fresh strawberries.

♦︎ Less Sweeteners: (i.e., sugar, etc.) - Almost all of the recipes I consulted as I was developing this recipe used a heavier hand with the sweeteners than my final recipe. I prefer to enhance the natural sweetness of the strawberries rather than overwhelm it. It's a delicate balance, based in part on how sweet your strawberries are.

What Goes into this Recipe

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

★ Fresh strawberries: Use fresh or fresh frozen strawberries for this recipe.

★ Sugar: Use plain, white granulated sugar.

★ Vodka: We use whipped cream vodka. Any 70/80 proof liquor will work.

As previously mentioned, the alcohol in the vodka keeps discourages water crystallization, which in turn keeps your little strawberry chunks from turning into little strawberry ice cubes.

If you prefer to avoid liquor completely, just leave it out. Your chopped strawberry chunks will be a bit crunchy, and the ice cream may get a little harder than optimal after a day or two in the freezer, but chances are it won't last that long anyway.

★ Half & Half: Yes, you can use heavy cream if you want. You can also use 1 cup of milk and 1 cup of heavy cream (but that's basically what half & half is, so why?).

We've tested this recipe using each of these three options, all with fine results; however, I think the lighter, cleaner flavor of the half & half lets the fresh strawberry flavors shine through most brightly.

★ Corn syrup: While we try to avoid corn syrup in most cases, we do use it in a number of our ice cream recipes, particularly the ones that are heavy on fruit. It adds texture and body, while discouraging ice crystal formation.

How to Make this Recipe

Hull all the strawberries. Chop enough strawberries to make one cup of chopped berries. You want the chunks to be pretty small; ¼-inch cubes or smaller.

Put the chopped strawberries in a small bowl with ¼ cup of sugar and the vodka. Refrigerate while you make the rest of the ice cream base.

Put remaining strawberries in a blender and puree. Measure out about 1½ cups of puree. If you have extra, put it in the fridge - you can use it for ice cream topping later!

Blend the 1½ cups of strawberry puree with the half and half, corn syrup, and salt. Taste the mixture and adjust the sweetness to your personal tastes by adding a little additional sugar if desired.

Chill the ice cream base in the blender jar in refrigerator for at least one hour.

Take the blender jar out of the fridge and add the chopped strawberry mixture. Pulse very briefly to combine. You want to keep those little chunks of strawberries, so don't get crazy here.

Churn in ice cream maker according to manufacturer directions. For reference, it usually takes 25 -30 minutes to freeze in our ice cream maker.

Serve immediately for soft serve ice cream. If you prefer your ice cream hard-set, put it in the freezer for 2-4 hours before serving.

More Fresh Strawberry Recipes

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, including Amazon affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that we have recommended. Please check out our disclosure policy for more details.