Pop's Spicy Garlic Dill Pickles

Pop's dill pickle recipe is legendary; spicy, garlicky, crunchy, and packed with all that old-fashion dill pickle flavor you long for and can't find in a store. 

Jump to:

• What's the Story Behind this Recipe?
• What Goes into Spicy Garlic Dills
• How to Make this Recipe
• FAQs & Expert Tips
• Related Recipes
• Pop's Spicy Garlic Dill Pickles

What's the Story Behind this Recipe?

George Smith Service Center Dills

My family has been using this heirloom dill pickle recipe for more than 70 years. A variation on "George Smith Service Dill Pickles," our version comes from my mother, who copied the recipe onto an envelope sometime in the 1960's. 

I remember Pop occasionally referring to our dill pickles as Service Dills, but as a child thought that was because they were originally made for people in the armed services. (My family was full of vets: it's a natural assumption for a kid to make.) 

As it turns out, I wasn't too far off the mark; but figuring that out took some work. When I first tried find a little background on this recipe, the only reference was a similar garlic dill pickle recipe from a member of the Daughters of Norway. I then reached out to my friend Gena, a genealogy expert who shares my love of heritage recipes and ephemera. Unfortunately, she was unable to find any reference to it among in her resources either. 

I finally located a few references to the George White Serve Center for World War II service men and women, which I learned was founded in Portland, Oregon in 1942. This aligns directly with my family history: Pop moved his entire family to Portland from the midwest in 1943 to work in the shipyards during the war.

The origin of this pickle recipe, on the other hand, remains something of a mystery; nevertheless, they are delicious, and well worth both the effort and the wait!

Pickled Memories

Pickling season is one of my earliest memories. Or rather, the smells of pickling season. I remember when I was about three or four, sitting on the top basement step and listening to the sharp clink of mason jars, and breathing in the briny scent of warm cucumbers and garlic that wafted up from Pop's basement canning kitchen.

My job was to run up and down the stairs whenever anyone needed anything. Sitting at the top of the stairs was a good place to watch and stay out of trouble. 

My mother, aunt, and grandpa made a line-assembly canning team worthy of Henry Ford. First there was Auntie (always a stickler for order) carefully packing fresh cucumbers into quart jars, puzzling more into each one than seemed humanly possible. Then Mom took the jar from her and searched for nooks and crannies between the tightly packed cucumbers, where she would pop in peppers, garlic, and dill before covering it all with a grape leaf blanket and lining it up on a clean tea towel.

When a batch was ready to be put into the canner, Pop would fill in the leftover spaces in each jar with hot, salty brine and place them in an enormous blue-speckled water-bath canner. They ran two canners for what seemed like all day: the work never ended until all the cucumbers were jarred. (In reality, you can process one batch, start to finish, in about an hour.) At the end of the day though, we had enough pickles for everyone to last at least a year, plus some to give away as gifts. 

After that, all I remember is a lot of waiting, because dill pickles must cure for at least six weeks after being made. If we ran out of pickles from the previous year before the new ones were ready, life seemed interminable. (I mean, how was I gonna make a peanut butter & dill pickle sandwich without them‽) 

What Goes into Spicy Garlic Dills

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

★ Cucumbers: Use medium pickling cucumbers, about 4-6 inches(max) in length. 

If you don't grow your own pickling cucumbers, visit your local farmers' market or contact your local farm association to find a cucumber farmer in your area. 

★ Water: In our town, the water is treated with enough chlorine that - without filtering, it can be easily tasted. If you have similar issues, but sure to use filtered water to make the brine. 

★ Vinegar: Use standard 5% white vinegar (the standard acidity range for most vinegars you buy in the store).

★ Pickling salt: Pickling salt, also known as canning salt, is a pure granulated salt (sodium chloride), without any anti-caking agents or additives. Finely textured, it dissolves more quickly that most other salts, and does not cloud.

Do not use table salt or sea salt in place of pickling salt. If you need a substitute for pickling salt, use the same weight of kosher salt. (Pickling salt and kosher salt measure differently.)

★ Fresh dill: Dill can be easily grown, or purchased in season at the farmers' market or at your local grocery store.

For dill pickles, you want to use the dill heads. These are the flowering tops on the dill plant. (The delicate, dark green dill fronds are perfect for using is sauces, soups, and drying for later use.)

The flavor of fresh dill is best just as it begins to flower. 

★ Dried red pepper pods: You need two dried arbol chiles for each quart of dills. These small, bright red dried pepper pods are widely available, and can be purchased at your local mercado, or grocery store in the Mexican food aisle. 

★ Garlic: You need two good-sized garlic cloves for each quart of pickles.

Peeling the garlic is perhaps the most difficult and tedious part of making dill pickles. The good news is, you can peel them ahead of time and stock them up in the refrigerator. (Or, even better, do what we do and buy them in bulk at Costco!) You can always roast any leftover garlic and use it as needed for cooking, and making compound butters, etc. 

★ Fresh grape leaves: Conveniently, grape leaves are abundant during the pickle-canning season. Find them at your local vineyard, farmers' market, or even your neighbor's backyard. Do not use jarred grape leaves.

Grape leaves release tannins which inhibit the enzymes that make pickles soft, helping your pickles to stay crisp. Some picklers believe that removing the blossom end of the cucumbers makes the addition of grape leaves unnecessary, but I'm not about to mess with Pop's pickle recipe.

You can substitute horseradish leaves for grape leaves. 

How to Make this Recipe

Prepare Cucumbers

Wash cucumbers to remove any dirt and debris and remove the blossom end of each cucumber.

Place cucumbers on ice for at least one hour before making brine. (Doing this helps the cucumbers stay crisper.)

Prep Jars & Lids

Prepare canning jars, lids, and rings for use.

Fill a water-bath canner about half full and set on high heat. Bring the water-bath to a boil while you prepare the pickles for canning.

Make Brine

To make the brine, combine vinegar, water, and salt in large stock pot or saucepan. Heat on HIGH, and bring the brine quickly to a boil. Remove from heat and set aside.

Pack Jars

Drain ice and water from cucumbers and pack the cold cucumbers tightly into quart jars, leaving at least ½-inch headspace. We try to use whole cucumbers as much as possible, but we always have to cut a few cukes to fit the small spaces. 

To each jar cucumber-packed jar, add 2 dried red pepper pods and 2 whole cloves of garlic. Slide the stem-end of one large or three small heads of dill into each jar. Maintain ½-inch headspace. 

Use only one dried pepper if you prefer your pickles less spicy. 

Cover each filled jar with one medium or large grape leaf.

Process Pickles

Reheat brine to a full boil. Ladle brine into the jars, covering the cucumbers and maintaining ½-inch headspace. Use a chopstick or plastic knife to remove any bubbles. If necessary, add more brine to maintain headspace. 

Wipe each jar rim with a wet paper towel or clean, wet cloth. Place a lid and ring on each jar and tighten.

Process both pint and quart jars in a 180° - 185°F [82° - 85°C] water bath for 20 minutes. 

Using a jar lifter, carefully place jars in hot water bath. 

There should be about one inch of water over the tops of the jars. Return canner to HIGH heat, cover, and bring to a simmer, processing for 20 minutes. (Start time only when water reaches a simmer again; 180° - 185°F [82° - 85°C].)

After processing, wait 5 minutes before removing the jars from the canner.

Place hot pickles jars on a cloth on the counter. Allow them to rest until completely cooled before storing.

Have Patience

Garlic Dills are ready to eat in 6 or 8 weeks.

FAQs & Expert Tips

Related Recipes

No Waiting! If you are in the mood for a pickle today, try our Swedish Cucumbers (Easy Quick Pickle), and check out our roundup of 27 Quick Pickle Recipes for Your Garden Bounty!

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, including Amazon affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that we have recommended. Please check out our disclosure policy for more details.